Showing posts with label Shadow banking system. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shadow banking system. Show all posts

Monday, March 17, 2014

What are the risks of shadow banking? - Sara Hsu

Sara Hsu
Sara Hsu
Financial analysts look at the financial risks of shadow banking from both extremes, some signal a looming collapse of China´s financial system, others claim there is not much to fear. For TripleCrisis shadow banking expert Sara Hsu explores the different kinds of financial products and their risks.

Sara Hsu:
In sum, the riskiest shadow banking sectors are the trust and wealth management product markets. These are mainly risky based on the integrity of the underlying loans. Many of these loans were extended through a process of adverse selection, with high risk borrowers like local government financing vehicles showing a willingness to pay high interest rates because they have no other choice. The adverse selection issue will play out in the trust and WMP industries, while shadow banking sectors that have lent to more creditworthy customers (as in the entrusted loan sector) or priced in risk (as in the corporate bond sector) will be shielded to some extent from this fallout.
More in TripleCrisis.

Sara Hsu is a speaker at the China Speakers Bureau. Do you need her at your meeting or conference? Do get in touch or fill in our speakers´request form.

Are you a media representative and do you want to talk to one of our speakers? Do get in touch.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Monday, February 10, 2014

More trouble ahead for trust funds - Sara Hsu

NTPU June 2012 7
Sara Hsu
China´s shadow banking industry escaped narrowly a major default in the last week of January, but more troubles is building up for the rest of 2014 as more trust funds are running into trouble, including gold mine scams, tells financial analyst Sara Hsu in the South China Morning Post. 

The South China Morning Post:
Despite evidence that underlying assets are failing in certain products, investor losses have been kept to a minimum as local governments or state-run institutions front the cash to maintain investor confidence. 
"My gut tells me that some big cases will be uncovered" given the slowdown in economic growth, said Sara Hsu, a professor at the State University of New York at New Paltz and an expert on shadow banking. 
"There has been a massive inflow of liquidity into infrastructure and property development up until this period, and where there are large liquidity inflows in a bubble environment, there is huge potential for the propagation of financial fraud. 
"The trust products that have failed so far have often had rumours of financial fraud associated with them."
More in the South China Morning Post.

Sara Hsu is a speaker at the China Speakers Bureau. Do you need her at your meeting or conference? Do get in touch or fill in our speakers´request form.  

 Are you a media representative and do you want to talk to one of our speakers? Do drop us a line. 
Enhanced by Zemanta

Tuesday, February 04, 2014

Why a melting shadow banking system is still possible - Sara Hsu


Sara HsuA narrow escape from default of the USD495 million of the trust fund, organized by the ICBC for the Shanxi Zhenfu Energy Group in the last week of January, is not the end of the troubles for other trust funds, writes shadow banking expert Sara Hsu in The Diplomat. "A liquidity crisis might expose more problems."

Sara Hsu:
A little publicized document called the “Trust Industry Risk Assessment Report,” released by Shanghai Jiaotong University, expands on these conclusions. After conducting stress tests on 60 trusts, the report found that solvency risk is relatively low, but that liquidity risk may present a real problem. 
The report also found that trust products are not priced for risk of the underlying asset. This, coupled with rapid expansion of the trust industry and with an implicit payment guarantee, has heightened the risks associated with trust products. The report does not mention the types of loans that trust products are based upon, and this is also a rising concern. Some of the trust loan defaults have been based on loans to the coal industry, which  has declined in profitability. A full third of trust loans have been extended to the real estate or infrastructure construction industries, which have experienced price bubbles and low levels of occupancy. Growth in these sectors is expected to decline in 2014. With these reversals, the credit risk associated with trust loans will only rise. 
All of these risks in fundamentals add to growing concern about China’s trust sector. This, coupled with a lack of regulation, and absence of risk control departments in most trust firms, sets the stage for a potential trust industry failure. Such an event may be triggered by an overall reversal in consumer sentiment—should households stop buying trust and wealth management products that contain these trust loans, the maturity mismatch inherent in the trust lending process (borrow short from households and lend long to firms) may truly present a problem. A liquidity crisis in the trust sector will expose some of the risks that have been covered up by steady income streams, and then these unregulated entities may face a final collapse.
More in The Diplomat.

Sara Hsu is a speaker at the China Speakers Bureau. Do you need her at your meeting or conference? Do get in touch or fill in our speakers´request form.
Enhanced by Zemanta

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

SME´s find it hard to get funding - Sara Hsu

Sara Hsu
+Sara Hsu 
January 31 is going to be a major test for the shadow banking in China, as a 3 billion RMB fund matures, without support of the larger banks. One of the main victims could be China´s SME, who had to turn to shadow banking as officials refused them funding, writes financial specialist Sara Hsu in the South China Morning Post.

Sara Hsu (co-authored with Andrew Collier):
What will happen to small business as China's economy slows? The country's small and medium-sized enterprises are an important part of the economy and even more integral to employment; they account for 60 per cent of gross domestic product but a full 82 per cent of employment. With China's GDP growth dropping from over 10 per cent three years ago to 7.5 per cent or below, SMEs are going to struggle, which could have a disastrous effect on China's future. 
The biggest problem facing them is a shortage of capital. The five state-owned banks, which control half of all bank assets, are much happier lending to state firms because they are generally "too big to fail". Even the smaller city and commercial banks prefer local-government-backed companies to private enterprise... 
Since the majority of the banking sector is owned by the central government in Beijing, including the state banks, they are well insulated from such liquidity shocks. 
But not the shadow banks. Unless they are large or well-connected enough to have direct ties to Beijing, they are not going to avail themselves of central government protection. 
There is a historical precedent for the failure of shadow banks in China. In 1989, regulators shuttered dozens of Wenzhou money houses or converted them to urban credit co-operative banks. 
Ten years later, suffering from growing bad loans, 18,000 rural co-operative foundations were either closed or taken over by a new group called Rural Credit Co-operatives, with much of the debt ending up back in the hands of the local governments. Such actions were prudent in light of weak lending controls and inadequate capital. But it also meant small business lost an important source of credit. 
The regulators, including the People's Bank of China and the China Banking Regulatory Commission, are aware of the risks. They are doing their best to push the official banks to lend to SMEs. 
In 2010, following orders from Beijing, SME loans jumped 34 per cent compared with a 20 per cent rise in total lending, according to Moody's. 
And last July, the authorities approved additional measures requiring state banks to lend to small businesses and provided new support for village and township banks. 
But all this may be in vain if China faces a new credit crunch. Like starving wheat during a drought, a crisis could lead thousands of small business to shrivel and die. It happened in Japan in the 1990s, again in the US during the mortgage crisis, and it could happen in China.
More in the South China Morning Post.

Sara Hsu is a speaker at the China Speakers Bureau. Do you need her at your meeting or conference? Do get in touch or fill in our speakers´request form.

China Weekly Hangout

The +China Weekly Hangout is on hibernation till after Chinese New Year. We will hold in between regular open office sessions, where you can drop in to figure out how hangouts work, discuss possible subjects and whatever might come on the table. Coming Thursday we will help you to get your hangout running and improve you settings. More info here. 

+Sara Hsu joined the +China Weekly Hangout on August 30 to explain how shadow banking in China works out, how big it is, and what the dangers are for China.

 
Enhanced by Zemanta

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

The rising risk for private investors in trusts - Sara Hsu

Sara Hsu
+Sara Hsu 
Trust companies have been taking on much of the local debts haunting China's economy. And most of their debts come from domestic investors in China, who bear most of the risk, when things go wrong, writes financial expert Sara Hsu in this weblog.

Sara Hsu
The China Banking Regulatory Commission, which took over the regulatory role for the TICs in 2003, established many guidelines for their operation. A serious investigation into the TICs was launched in 2004, and a number of scandals were uncovered; by 2005, the number of TICs had unsurprisingly diminished. 
The reincarnation of TICs as trust companies is a result of a 2007 regulation that improved corporate governance and restricted the use of trust companies’ own assets. With the CBRC as a regulatory body, new regulations, and new names, trust companies became quite appealing to the Chinese public. Between 2008 and 2013, trust industry assets under management increased more than seven-fold. Without quite realizing that these companies have a tendency to encumber excessive risks, taking on loans that banks might be prevented from extending directly, the public has viewed trust products simply as deliverers of yield. 
The difference between the TICs and the trusts is that risk among trusts is concentrated among domestic, rather than foreign, holders of trust assets. CBRC officials have been adamant that (domestic) holders of shadow banking products, particularly wealth management products, are the ultimate bearers of risk. In an increasingly market oriented economy, allowing institutions and individuals who take on risks to bear the cost of the risks will likely be more commonplace. And why would the government prop up a flagging industry that has behaved badly in the past, should the economic climate turn sour? The simple truth is that it seems unlikely. The trusts are in danger of joining the TICs in yet another restructuring debacle. This may be the least surprising event in China’s restructuring mix.
You can read her full story here.

Sara Hsu is a speaker at the China Speakers Bureau. Do you need her at your meeting or conference? Do get in touch or fill in our speakers' request form.

Sara Hsu joined the +China Weekly Hangout on August 30 to discuss the perils of shadow banking in China.
 
Enhanced by Zemanta

Friday, November 29, 2013

High concern for economic slowdown - Sara Hsu

+Sara Hsu 
Speculative investments in shadow banking are raising concerns for a economic slowdown in China, writes financial expert Sara Hsu in The Diplomat. She pleads for dealing with shadow banking in stead of monetary tightening.

Sara Hsu:
There is growing concern that China’s economy may face a slowdown because of speculative investments in local government financing vehicles and real estate. This type of crisis would mirror that which occurred in the U.S. in 2007-2008, with asset price declines in real estate leading to liquidity and solvency issues in overleveraged financial institutions, triggering a financial crisis. Although China’s financial leverage ratios are not as high as those in the U.S. preceding the crisis, and the Chinese government is often considered a backstop for the loan operations of the banking system, there is still good reason for this concern... 
China financial scholars are eminently aware that something grim lies ahead and many are hopeful that reforms to be pushed through by President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang will resolve some of the negative financial outlook. However, even if the financial sector is reined in, it seems the only way to really overcome this unstable “speculative spread” is to specifically target the shadow banking sector and curb its activity. It has been noted that monetary tightening will lead to a slowdown in credit growth and GDP, but it may not have the effect of curbing the shadow banking sector compared to less risky financial activity, and could even exacerbate the speculative spread. 
Therefore policy aimed directly at the shadow banking sector is a far better idea: it could eliminate the threat of financial instability at its root. Reducing the risk of loans extended by trusts, or through banks as entrusted loans, and curbing the issuance of bankers’ acceptance bills can rein in the growing speculation and help to balance China’s financial sector as it is further reformed. As the financial sector is gradually liberalized and developed, the financial sector may be able to better handle the creation of non-standard debt assets. 
Right now, however, this is something that should not be overlooked and presents a real threat to the Chinese economy. As sexy as it is to study illicit financial flows—particularly for those who profit from them—China watchers are right in fearing the intangible financial instability inherent in China’s current composition of financial flows.
More in The Diplomat.

Sara Hsu is a speaker at the China Speakers Bureau. Do you need her at your meeting or conference? Do get in touch or fill in our speakers' request form.


Enhanced by Zemanta

Monday, November 18, 2013

Third Plenum does not solve financial instability - Sara Hsu

NTPU June 2012 7
+Sara Hsu 
The reforms announced after the Third Plenum might not offer a enough to guarantee financial stability in China, writes financial specialist Sara Hsu in Triple Crisis. China's financial authorities should focus on shadow banking, in stead of monetary tightening that could slow down economic growth. 

Sara Hsu:
China financial scholars are eminently aware that something grim lies ahead and many are hopeful that the Third Plenum this weekend will resolve some of the negative financial outlook. To me, it’s not obvious that the Third Plenum will automatically resolve China’s financial instability—it seems the only way to really overcome this unstable “speculative spread” is to specifically target the shadow banking sector to curb its activity. It has been noted that monetary tightening will lead to a slowdown in credit growth and GDP, but it may not have the effect of curbing the shadow banking sector as opposed to M3, and could even exacerbate the speculative spread. Therefore policy aimed directly at the shadow banking sector is a far better idea—it could eliminate the threat of financial instability at its root. 
China financial scholars are right in fearing the financial instability inherent in China’s current composition of financial flows. As “sexy” as it may be to study illicit financial flows—particularly for those who profit off of them—this is something that should not be overlooked and presents a real threat to the Chinese economy.
More in Triple Crisis.

Sara Hsu is a speaker at the China Speakers Bureau. Do you need her at your meeting or conference? Do get in touch or fill in our speakers' request form.

China Weekly Hangout

The Third Plenum

Labor camps, the one-child policy, hukou's, pollution, internet censorship, state-owned companies, energy policy: they are just a few of the subjects that appeared last week in the 21,000 character document released after the Third Plenum of the Communist Party, spelling out reform plans for the coming years. The +China Weekly Hangout plans to discuss some of those plans and will ask panelist whether the Third Plenum did bear a mouse or an elephant. Pending a few logistical challenges, we will hold our online meeting on 21 November at 10pm Beijing time, 3pm CET and 9am EST. We will pick subjects, depending on the expertise of the people joining us on Thursday, and summarize with the question how likely it is president Xi Jinping will pull off the planned reforms.

Is China going to collapse under the burden of its debts, the +China Weekly Hangout asked on August 31. Yes, if they do not play their cards rights, tells Sara Hsu, leading expert on shadow banking in China. Questions are asked by +Fons Tuinstra of the China Speakers Bureau.
Enhanced by Zemanta